Both perform well in hurricanes when they're Miami-Dade approved and installed correctly — the installation matters more than the material. Standing seam metal is lighter with no tiles to break or blow off; tile is heavier, very long-lasting and the classic South Florida look.
| Standing seam metal | Concrete / clay tile | |
|---|---|---|
| Weight | Light | Heavy — the structure must support it |
| Typical Miami cost | $25,000–$45,000 | $20,000–$35,000 (concrete) |
| Storm weak point | Edges and trim if poorly fastened | Flying debris can crack tiles; ridge and hip tiles |
| Lifespan | 40+ years | Tile 30+ years; underlayment ~20–25 |
| Heat | Reflective finishes help keep attics cooler | Mass and air gap help with heat |
Both are generally more resistant to high-wind damage than shingles. Other options worth a look: Brava composite tile, which looks like clay but is lighter and impact-rated, and modern architectural shingles for budget-conscious projects.
The right choice also depends on your home's structure, HOA rules and budget. We install all of them and will give you prices on more than one option.