Often, yes. On a tile roof the tiles shed most of the water, but the underlayment beneath them is the real waterproofing — and in South Florida it typically wears out around 20–25 years, long before the tiles do. When it fails, leaks start even though the tiles look perfect.
Signs the underlayment is the problem:
- Leaks or ceiling stains on a tile roof with few broken tiles
- The roof is around 20+ years old
- Repairs keep "fixing" leaks that come back nearby
The fix is a tile re-roof: tiles are removed, the old underlayment is torn off, the deck is inspected and re-nailed, new self-adhered underlayment goes down, and tiles are reinstalled or replaced. Whether old tiles can be reused depends on how many break during removal, whether matching tile is still available, and whether the tile and attachment meet current Miami-Dade approvals.
A new sealed underlayment can also help with your wind-mitigation report. We'll inspect from the attic and the roof and tell you whether you need a re-roof or a repair.